Score: 9

"nice work"

submission: *We Didn't Start the Fire

date: December 3, 2009

Really, a great flash with slick animation. It's not my favorite version of this music video, but it is the most humorous. I wouldn't expect the average newgroundser to recognize more than a few of these, but it really is well done.

Score: 3

"Not good"

submission: Sixty Seconds

date: November 26, 2009

Really, this game isn't fun. You click the mouse a few times. No story, one picture, and annoying music. Skill, shmill. This simply isn't a good game.

Score: 5

"Not good enough"

submission: Captain Crash

date: November 22, 2009

I was hoping for a decent toss game, which there are dozens of. Instead, I got a mediocre one. The ugly, repeating backgrounds. The lack of upgrades, other than "higher hang time", "longer distances", and "longer bounces." The costumes which are just changes in hairdo. And of course, the utterly stupid system of money only being collected by picking it up, not by going a long distance or anything like that. Add the originally catchy but quickly becomes annoying theme song, and I have a lame excuse for a toss game. Fly squirrel fly, toss the turtle, and dozens of others do what this game does a thousand times better. This is not a hard game to make. So why does it suck?